Memory & Redemption

Reflections on Jewish life from within

  • Home
  • About Yael Shahar
    • Yael Shahar – Author bio
    • Becoming a Different Yael Shahar
    • The Revival of the Dead: A personal journey
    • Writing as Self-Transformation: Kasva Press interviews Yael Shahar
    • Book a speaking engagement, lecture, or interactive workshop
    • Contact Yael Shahar
  • For Book Clubs & Educators
    • Resources for Book Clubs & Educators
    • About the Book
    • Reader’s guide
    • Reflections & Resources on T’shuvah – Free download
    • Moral Dilemmas in the Holocaust: Discussion topics
    • Returning: Glossary of Hebrew terms
  • Blog: Reflections & Musings
You are here: Home / Hashkafah & Jewish Thought / Of Tithes and Greenhouses

Of Tithes and Greenhouses

July 10, 2015 by Yael Shahar 1 Comment

Grapes4Rav Ish-Shalom met me at the door with a smile and a cup of coffee. We exchanged our news of the week, and then settled into learning Massechet Taanit.

The first phrase on the page before us (Taanit 9a) was:

עשר תעשר.” עשר בשביל שתתעשר”

“Tithe (with the word repeated to emphasize command) so that you will grow rich.”

The fact that “tithe” (asser) is spelled the same as “rich” (ashir) allowed R’ Yochanan to teach: If you give freely to the poor, you will be given to.

“This is the pasuk from which we derive the idea that one takes t’rumot u’Ma’aserot from one’s fields, but not from a crops grown in a greenhouse,” said Rav Ish-Shalom.

“But wait a minute,” I said, “it can’t be that crops grown in a greenhouse are exempt; it’s the same soil! How can you justify not giving Ma’aserot from those crops?!”

“Is it the same soil? We don’t give Ma’aserot from crops grown in a house.”

“Well, but a greenhouse isn’t a house; it’s just a roof placed over the fields. Does one put a Mezuzah on a greenhouse?!”

At this point, Rav Ish-Shalom got that gleeful look that he gets sometimes when I challenge his reasoning. “Ah, but what have we done by building a greenhouse?” he asked. “For better or worse, we’ve built our own little ecosystem, independent of Hashem’s rain and Hashem’s weather!  We are told to take Ma’aserot of our crops to remind us that the crops are not ours. But the crops grown in the greenhouse are ours! We have provided the conditions for their growth, for better or for worse! We have determined the conditions for the plants’ growth. We may ensure a good crop, but by taking control of the outcome, we are denied the mitzvah.”

Well, this simply bowled me over. We give Ma’aser of what we don’t own, to show us that we had no input in its production. We don’t give Ma’aser of our own, because we are the owners.

“This is what we do in raising children,” my teacher continued. “We raise them in greenhouses. We try to deny Hashem any influence. We don’t want our children exposed to the vagaries of chance. But if we overdo this, we run the risk of keeping God out of our children’s lives. If I try to arrange for my son to marry someone that I, in my over-inflated wisdom, see as a perfect match, rather than allowing Hashem to arrange for his meeting with his true beshert in the normal course of human interaction, I have short-circuited hashgacha pratit (Divine providence). The marriage may well work out. But I am denied the mitzva.”

In the course of ten minutes of learning Gemara, he taught me something that I could have lived years without learning.  It’s clear why people like Rav Ish-Shalom are the channels of Matan Torah. But I suppose we function as such channels to each other at all times. Just that most of the time, we are unaware of it.

 

Filed Under: Hashkafah & Jewish Thought Tagged With: Massechet Ta'anit, Rav Ish-Shalom, Talmud Study

About Yael Shahar

After an adventurous and unattributable career in security and intelligence, Yael Shahar now divides her time between researching trends in terrorism and learning Talmud with anyone who will sit still long enough. She is an entertaining and sought-after public speaker, and lectures both in Israel and abroad.

Dazzling… Returning is an extraordinary and challenging book on many levels.
– Philip K. Jason, Washington Independent Review of Books

Intriguing! At times dark and haunting, at times lyrical and introspective, Returning resonates long after “the end”!
– Dan Sofer, author of the Dry Bones Society trilogy

Returning is a compelling, puzzling, remarkably honest story of a Jew’s sins against his people and his tradition, and of his search for forgiveness and restoration.
– Bill Tammeus, Faith Matters

Free Download

Related Posts

  • The Tanur shel Akhnai: A tale of two methods
  • The Response to a Blessing and the Hidden Lessons of the Kaddish
  • Rabbi Yochanan & Resh Lakish: A lesson in interpretation
  • Whoopi Goldberg and the Jewish Question
  • HaRav Adin Steinsaltz: A place at the four dimensional table

Recent Posts

  • The Great Hanukkah Cover-up: self-censorship and national survival
  • The Time of Our Rejoicing – In spite of everything
  • Making order of the Passover Seder
  • The Post War Challenge: Learning from successes as well as failures
  • Knowing the Way Home

Main Topics

  • Book Reviews
  • Featured
  • Guest Posts
  • Halakhic Process
  • Hashkafah & Jewish Thought
  • Havruta with a One-Eyed Cat
  • Memory & History
  • Miscellaneous
  • Parashat HaShavua
  • Poetry
  • Returning
  • T'shuvah & Healing
  • The Jewish Year
  • Writing & Publishing

“We stand on the edge of the abyss, across whose unknowable face we paint meaning so as not to see into it. It is always there. But we’re here too, and we are no less real than the abyss. We are no less meaningful for being transient creatures caught up in something too big for us. There is still value to our lives. I’ve learned that those things that are most fragile are also the most precious.”

 

― Ovadya ben Malka, Returning

Proudly hosted by:

Web Hosting

© 2026 · Yael Shahar · Built by Kasva Press