Memory & Redemption

Reflections on Jewish life from within

  • Home
  • About Yael Shahar
    • Yael Shahar – Author bio
    • Becoming a Different Yael Shahar
    • The Revival of the Dead: A personal journey
    • Writing as Self-Transformation: Kasva Press interviews Yael Shahar
    • Book a speaking engagement, lecture, or interactive workshop
    • Contact Yael Shahar
  • For Book Clubs & Educators
    • Resources for Book Clubs & Educators
    • About the Book
    • Reader’s guide
    • Reflections & Resources on T’shuvah – Free download
    • Moral Dilemmas in the Holocaust: Discussion topics
    • Returning: Glossary of Hebrew terms
  • Blog: Reflections & Musings
You are here: Home / Havruta with a One-Eyed Cat / Sanhedrin Perek 3 – Grass roots vs. rule from above

Sanhedrin Perek 3 – Grass roots vs. rule from above

December 24, 2012 by Yael Shahar Leave a Comment

Pixel

I ended up preparing for my advanced Talmud class with Pixel as Havruta. It might have been easier to study on my own, but she left me no choice; she sat on the arm of my chair and read over my shoulder.

Sanhedrin Perek 3, Mishna 1. “Financial cases are judged by three…”

“Pet the cat,” said Pixel. I shifted the heavy volume to free up my cat-petting hand.

“The litigants each choose a judge and then both together choose the third judge. This is the opinion of Rabbi Meir.”

Hmmm… But why would R’ Meir think that two people who can’t even agree on who owes how much to whom are suddenly going to agree on the third judge?

“R’ Meir is over-ruled…as usual,” said Pixel.  “He’s always in the minority.”

“Come on, Pixel! What does a cat know about judiciary matters?”

Pixel gave me one of those looks. “You’ll see. Letting the litigants decide who will judge their case leaves the way open to all sorts of problems…. What if the litigants choose a miscreant? What if they choose someone who is related to one of the litigants. That’s less likely to happen if the third judge gets chosen by the previous two judges.”

Gemara: “The sages rule that the two judges together choose the third judge”.

“See?” said Pixel. “Human beings aren’t competent. You have to legislate for the lowest common denominator. All this will be straightened out when Bertrum Thumbcat takes over the world… Pet the cat.”

“But wait a minute, Pixel. The two litigants each chose one of the first two judges. So there’s some concession to the grassroots level.”

Pixel was not impressed. “That’s just so human beings won’t feel too despondent and unworthy of petting cats.” She paused to lick a bit of fur back into place. “You see, Rabbi Meir was trying to legislate for an unrealistically ideal world. That’s why he’s always in the minority. And then there was that little matter of Elisha ben Abuya… Pet the cat.”

How can so much irreverence be packed into such a tiny body, not to mention smugness? “Pixel, stop dissing R’ Meir!  He was born over 2,000 years ago; you were born less than 10 years ago. And also, he’s Bruria’s husband. He outranks you. Besides, you’re a cat.”

“Does Bruria feed cats? Does she live on our street? No. She’s irrelevant. Pet the cat. NOW!”

(Petting cat….)

Filed Under: Havruta with a One-Eyed Cat Tagged With: Gemara, havruta, Pixel, Sanhedrin, Talmud

About Yael Shahar

After an adventurous and unattributable career in security and intelligence, Yael Shahar now divides her time between researching trends in terrorism and learning Talmud with anyone who will sit still long enough. She is an entertaining and sought-after public speaker, and lectures both in Israel and abroad.

Dazzling… Returning is an extraordinary and challenging book on many levels.
– Philip K. Jason, Washington Independent Review of Books

Intriguing! At times dark and haunting, at times lyrical and introspective, Returning resonates long after “the end”!
– Dan Sofer, author of the Dry Bones Society trilogy

Returning is a compelling, puzzling, remarkably honest story of a Jew’s sins against his people and his tradition, and of his search for forgiveness and restoration.
– Bill Tammeus, Faith Matters

Free Download

Related Posts

  • Gemara Sanhedrin 73a – Saving the victim or saving the perpetrator?
  • Pessachim 10a and Quantum Uncertainty
  • Truth, Compromise, and Meta-Halakhah
  • Rabbi Yochanan & Resh Lakish: A lesson in interpretation
  • Pixel’s Secrets of Google Indexing

Recent Posts

  • The Great Hanukkah Cover-up: self-censorship and national survival
  • The Time of Our Rejoicing – In spite of everything
  • Making order of the Passover Seder
  • The Post War Challenge: Learning from successes as well as failures
  • Knowing the Way Home

Main Topics

  • Book Reviews
  • Featured
  • Guest Posts
  • Halakhic Process
  • Hashkafah & Jewish Thought
  • Havruta with a One-Eyed Cat
  • Memory & History
  • Miscellaneous
  • Parashat HaShavua
  • Poetry
  • Returning
  • T'shuvah & Healing
  • The Jewish Year
  • Writing & Publishing

“We stand on the edge of the abyss, across whose unknowable face we paint meaning so as not to see into it. It is always there. But we’re here too, and we are no less real than the abyss. We are no less meaningful for being transient creatures caught up in something too big for us. There is still value to our lives. I’ve learned that those things that are most fragile are also the most precious.”

 

― Ovadya ben Malka, Returning

Proudly hosted by:

Web Hosting

© 2026 · Yael Shahar · Built by Kasva Press