Memory & Redemption

Reflections on Jewish life from within

  • Home
  • About Yael Shahar
    • Yael Shahar – Author bio
    • Becoming a Different Yael Shahar
    • The Revival of the Dead: A personal journey
    • Writing as Self-Transformation: Kasva Press interviews Yael Shahar
    • Book a speaking engagement, lecture, or interactive workshop
    • Contact Yael Shahar
  • For Book Clubs & Educators
    • Resources for Book Clubs & Educators
    • About the Book
    • Reader’s guide
    • Reflections & Resources on T’shuvah – Free download
    • Moral Dilemmas in the Holocaust: Discussion topics
    • Returning: Glossary of Hebrew terms
  • Blog: Reflections & Musings
You are here: Home / Poetry / The Night a Sonderkommando absolved God

The Night a Sonderkommando absolved God

May 1, 2019 by Yael Shahar Leave a Comment

He won’t remember it.
Striving with all he’s got to forget,
he won’t remember this either:
how the mind wanders as he goes about the routine.
The routine.
That’s how he’s come to see it now.
Just routine.

So he won’t remember railing at God as he sorted through gloves,
putting the ones burned through at the fingers at the back,
piling the better ones at the front.
Always sorting here. The useful from the worthless.
The healthy from the sick,
The living from the dead.

He was on the other side of the sorting,
He was still useful.
And so just part of the routine.
And yet, something in his mind remembered outrage,
Cursed at God in the language of the lager,
which is no language at all.

El Maleh Rahamim…
The God full of mercy?
Where was your mercy just now,
in that room full of agony?
Upstairs where we feed our people to the flames…
Where is Your famous mercy now?

The roar of ventilators would have swallowed the answer
had there been one.

Ahavah Rabbah….
With great love You have loved us….?
Like the love with which you ushered us into Birkenau?
With an outstretched arm, eh?
Love!

Love….
The thought breaks through his rant…
Where was our love?
Where was our mercy on our own?
Just now, in that room full of agony…
Where was our tenderness toward those who asked of us only hope?

We have no hope to give….
But could we not have at least been gentle?

Maybe You aren’t here with us, he mutters in Ladino,
as he pours bleach into buckets beside the door.
Maybe You aren’t…

But we are.

He won’t remember any of this.
Tonight, he will drink himself into a stupor and rail at God in his dreams.
He won’t remember absolving God of the sins of man.

But I will.
I who have folded his memories into the depth of my being,
folding decades and losses into life,
I will remember.

Share this:

  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Print (Opens in new window) Print
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • More
  • Share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
  • Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn

Filed Under: Memory & History, Miscellaneous, Poetry Tagged With: forgiveness, sonderkommando

About Yael Shahar

After an adventurous and unattributable career in security and intelligence, Yael Shahar now divides her time between researching trends in terrorism and learning Talmud with anyone who will sit still long enough. She is an entertaining and sought-after public speaker, and lectures both in Israel and abroad.

Dazzling… Returning is an extraordinary and challenging book on many levels.
– Philip K. Jason, Washington Independent Review of Books

Intriguing! At times dark and haunting, at times lyrical and introspective, Returning resonates long after “the end”!
– Dan Sofer, author of the Dry Bones Society trilogy

Returning is a compelling, puzzling, remarkably honest story of a Jew’s sins against his people and his tradition, and of his search for forgiveness and restoration.
– Bill Tammeus, Faith Matters

Free Download

Related Posts

  • When no one survives to forgive
  • For Those Who Wrote: The attempts by the Birkenau Sonderkommando to leave a record
  • Message Delivered: A Sonderkommando speaks
  • Priorities and Charity: A Sonderkommando’s lesson in humanity
  • Son of Saul and the role of art after the Holocaust

Popular Posts

  • Yael Shahar - Home
    Yael Shahar - Home
  • The Tanur shel Akhnai: A tale of two methods
    The Tanur shel Akhnai: A tale of two methods
  • Chaos Theory, Goedel's Proof, and Halakhah: Thoughts on undirected Halakhic process
    Chaos Theory, Goedel's Proof, and Halakhah: Thoughts on undirected Halakhic process
  • Yael Shahar Blog
    Yael Shahar Blog
  • Parashat Terumah: The Tent of the King
    Parashat Terumah: The Tent of the King
  • Book Review: An Unexpected Afterlife by Dan Sofer
    Book Review: An Unexpected Afterlife by Dan Sofer
  • Yael Shahar - Author bio
    Yael Shahar - Author bio
  • Death & Transcendence – a Jewish perspective
    Death & Transcendence – a Jewish perspective
  • Rabbi Yochanan & Resh Lakish: A lesson in interpretation
    Rabbi Yochanan & Resh Lakish: A lesson in interpretation
  • Book Review: The Disappearance of God by Richard Elliot Friedman
    Book Review: The Disappearance of God by Richard Elliot Friedman

Main Topics

  • Book Reviews
  • Featured
  • Guest Posts
  • Halakhic Process
  • Hashkafah & Jewish Thought
  • Havruta with a One-Eyed Cat
  • Memory & History
  • Miscellaneous
  • Parashat HaShavua
  • Poetry
  • Returning
  • T'shuvah & Healing
  • The Jewish Year
  • Writing & Publishing

Connect with me on Facebook

Connect with me on Facebook

Proudly hosted by:

Web Hosting

© 2026 · Yael Shahar · Built by Kasva Press