Memory & Redemption

Reflections on Jewish life from within

A Damaged Mirror

 

Read the Foreword by Rabbi Nathan Lopes Cardozo.

 

Start reading online now!
Or download a Sample Chapter

 

Excerpts from A Damaged Mirror

Recent Posts

  • The Great Hanukkah Cover-up: self-censorship and national survival
  • The Time of Our Rejoicing – In spite of everything
  • Making order of the Passover Seder
  • The Post War Challenge: Learning from successes as well as failures
  • Knowing the Way Home

Topics

  • Home
  • About Yael Shahar
    • Yael Shahar – Author bio
    • Becoming a Different Yael Shahar
    • The Revival of the Dead: A personal journey
    • Writing as Self-Transformation: Kasva Press interviews Yael Shahar
    • Book a speaking engagement, lecture, or interactive workshop
    • Contact Yael Shahar
  • For Book Clubs & Educators
    • Resources for Book Clubs & Educators
    • About the Book
    • Reader’s guide
    • Reflections & Resources on T’shuvah – Free download
    • Moral Dilemmas in the Holocaust: Discussion topics
    • Returning: Glossary of Hebrew terms
  • Blog: Reflections & Musings

Musings on an unremembered past

From the moment I set foot in Israel, I began to feel that I had no idea who I really was…

Well, of course I knew!  I had a clear picture of my childhood, growing up in the southern United States, training horses, teaching astronomy, and working toward a degree in physics. I had wanted to work in field theory and my sights were set on the University of Texas at Austin, home of John A. Wheeler and his school of gravitational theory.

My closest friend was now a graduate student there, and regaled me with stories of his internship at the observatory in the Davis Mountains. “Once, a madman with a shotgun broke into the observatory and opened fire at the 80-inch telescope mirror.” Apparently the mirror, despite its wounds, could still reflect starlight into the waiting cameras. Starlight became time—photons that had traveled for thousands of years across empty space, only to go “splat” on a photographic plate, and deliver a message from the distant past.

Story of my life.

Yes, I could remember all this; I knew it intimately. The trouble was: it was not my life story; it was not my past.  It was as if it had all happened to someone else, and in its place was another past entirely. This one I knew just as intimately. Except that I could not remember it.

It swirled around in my mind, sometimes rising close enough to the surface that I could almost reach out and touch it. At other times, it would send out tantalizing hints, a random smell would trigger a flash of… what? An image, a momentary recognition of something, a glimmer of memory, just out of sight.  Spices in the market in the Old City, the sound of an oud drifting from the back room of some Arab restaurant. I would stop to listen, momentarily transfixed, as the multi-colored crowds of Middle Eastern shoppers, tourists, and pilgrims parted to go around me.  For those moments I was unreachable. I was home.

And then it would hit me: a sense of loss and desolation so overwhelming as to leave me speechless and sightless.  Always the same pattern. Where was that “home” that I seemed to have lost so completely that no memory of it remained to me?  And how had I come to lose it?

For lost it I very obviously had. But I did know where I had lost it. More to the point, I knew when I had lost it; I knew the exact date. That date would be the starting point of my quest for my vanished past, whose light still glimmered, like the light of long-dead stars, reflected by the wounded mirror of the present.

And are we not, all of us, in some way damaged mirrors? Are we not constantly engaged in focusing the light of thought—memories out of the depths of human experience—onto the photographic plate of each moment? The image captured in this instant is a snapshot of all eternity, subtly altered by our own brokenness. And who’s to say that the image formed by the damaged mirror is not a truer picture of the universe?

Share this:

  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Print (Opens in new window) Print
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • More
  • Share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
  • Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn

Dazzling… Returning is an extraordinary and challenging book on many levels.
– Philip K. Jason, Washington Independent Review of Books

Intriguing! At times dark and haunting, at times lyrical and introspective, Returning resonates long after “the end”!
– Dan Sofer, author of the Dry Bones Society trilogy

Returning is a compelling, puzzling, remarkably honest story of a Jew’s sins against his people and his tradition, and of his search for forgiveness and restoration.
– Bill Tammeus, Faith Matters

Free Download

Popular Posts

  • Parashat Terumah: The Tent of the King
    Parashat Terumah: The Tent of the King
  • HaRav Adin Steinsaltz: A place at the four dimensional table
    HaRav Adin Steinsaltz: A place at the four dimensional table
  • We have met the enemy... The Jewish terrorists among us
    We have met the enemy... The Jewish terrorists among us
  • Book Review: The Disappearance of God by Richard Elliot Friedman
    Book Review: The Disappearance of God by Richard Elliot Friedman
  • The Law of the King: individual commandment or national constitution?
    The Law of the King: individual commandment or national constitution?
  • Book Review: An Unexpected Afterlife by Dan Sofer
    Book Review: An Unexpected Afterlife by Dan Sofer
  • It is not in Heaven: Musings on the Meaning of Torah min Shamayim
    It is not in Heaven: Musings on the Meaning of Torah min Shamayim
  • Yael Shahar - Home
    Yael Shahar - Home
  • Haveil Havelim Jewish Blog Carnival
    Haveil Havelim Jewish Blog Carnival

Main Topics

  • Book Reviews
  • Featured
  • Guest Posts
  • Halakhic Process
  • Hashkafah & Jewish Thought
  • Havruta with a One-Eyed Cat
  • Memory & History
  • Miscellaneous
  • Parashat HaShavua
  • Poetry
  • Returning
  • T'shuvah & Healing
  • The Jewish Year
  • Writing & Publishing
Yael Shahar

Yael Shahar

Yael Shahar is the author of Returning. She spent most of her career working in security and intelligence, with brief forays into teaching astronomy and physics. She now divides her time between researching trends in terrorism and learning Talmud with anyone who will sit still long enough.

View Full Profile →

divider3

"In those circumstances we are reduced to bare existence, bereft of all that we once believed to define us. Naked, we have no pockets in which to store the things that we once used in the natural trade of human interactions. Instead, we come to value a different currency—our humanity. It is this currency that truly defines us, and even death cannot entirely devalue it. The more is taken away, the more we value what is left."

 

- Ovadya ben Malka, A Damaged Mirror

divider3

“We stand on the edge of the abyss, across whose unknowable face we paint meaning so as not to see into it. It is always there. But we’re here too, and we are no less real than the abyss. We are no less meaningful for being transient creatures caught up in something too big for us. There is still value to our lives. I’ve learned that those things that are most fragile are also the most precious.”

 

― Ovadya ben Malka, A Damaged Mirror

Top Posts & Pages

  • Parashat Terumah: The Tent of the King
  • HaRav Adin Steinsaltz: A place at the four dimensional table
  • We have met the enemy... The Jewish terrorists among us
  • Book Review: The Disappearance of God by Richard Elliot Friedman
  • The Law of the King: individual commandment or national constitution?
  • Book Review: An Unexpected Afterlife by Dan Sofer
  • It is not in Heaven: Musings on the Meaning of Torah min Shamayim
  • Yael Shahar - Home
  • Haveil Havelim Jewish Blog Carnival
Cover_3D_small

 

With a new Foreword by Rabbi Nathan Lopes Cardozo.

View a Sample Chapter

 

Excerpts from A Damaged Mirror

Main Topics

  • Book Reviews
  • Featured
  • Guest Posts
  • Halakhic Process
  • Hashkafah & Jewish Thought
  • Havruta with a One-Eyed Cat
  • Memory & History
  • Miscellaneous
  • Parashat HaShavua
  • Poetry
  • Returning
  • T'shuvah & Healing
  • The Jewish Year
  • Writing & Publishing

Connect with me on Facebook

Connect with me on Facebook

Proudly hosted by:

Web Hosting

© 2026 · Yael Shahar · Built by Kasva Press